Yoga and Meditation: A Comparative Analysis
Author: Dr. Gian Kumar (PhD)
Yoga originated in the ancient Indus Valley civilization around India about 5,000 years ago. The Rig Veda, compiled 3,000 to 3,500 years ago, is the earliest known reference to yoga, where it describes achieving transcendence through control of thoughts and emotions. More structured forms of yoga developed in later times.
One of the important texts on yoga is the Yoga Sutras of Patanjali, compiled around the 2nd century BCE. Patanjali's 196 sutras cover various aspects of yoga practice, including ethical principles, body postures, breath control, sense withdrawal, concentration, meditation and the state of Samadhi. The spiritual science of yoga consists of two basic principles – consciousness and meditation. The only difference is that meditation does not necessarily require movement, whereas yoga consists of both. The essence of yoga is to balance the movements of the body and mind with an awakened soul.
Meditation is not holistic, it is an element of yoga. Moreover, meditation can lead to ego inflation due to a false sense of security, leading one to boast about the subject rather than practicing the same mindfully. Unless all three aspects of the human self are involved – body, mind and soul – the results can be discriminatory. In the pursuit of holistic well-being, yoga and meditation emerged together as popular practices. Thus, yoga is holistic, while meditation deals primarily with quieting the mind. Though they are interrelated and share a common goal of improving mental and physical health, they are different disciplines with specific approaches and benefits. This article delves into the differences, benefits and potential integration between yoga and meditation, providing insight into how each can contribute to a balanced lifestyle.
Rooted in ancient Indian traditions, yoga is a holistic practice that integrates physical postures (asana), breath control (pranayama), and meditation (dhyana). The word “yoga” means “union” and reflects the goal of integrating the mind, body, and soul. Practicing yoga postures before meditation helps prepare the mind and body for deeper meditation. Physical activity releases tension, increases circulation, and brings calm, making it easier to focus during meditation. Creating a structured routine with dedicated time for yoga exercises and meditation ensures a balanced approach to physical and mental health. Although yoga and meditation are different, they offer a comprehensive approach to holistic health. Yoga's physical postures and breath control prepare the mind and body for the stillness and focus required for meditation. Understanding and integrating these practices allows individuals to achieve a balanced state of physical vitality and mental stillness, enhancing the overall quality of life. The key is consistency and mindfulness, which over time unleash the transformative effects.
Yoga cultivates self-awareness primarily by focusing on the mind, which is crucial in discerning reality. The mind brings challenges and stress, but it is important to overcome it. Thought control is possible through self-awareness. Mind control does not involve stopping thoughts, but using them effectively, which is possible through introspection, that is, observing the body and mind without questioning or interference. The mind that we can understand is limited to the conscious mind that is active when we are awake with emotional desires. It is only a part of the overall mind. It is futile to try to influence the consciousness. We also need to know how to enter the realm of spontaneous intuition, where the mind functions beyond thoughts and cognitive states, and tap into the potential of the soul.
Recognizing the limitations of consciousness is important for living in the present. It is interesting to delve deeply into the mechanisms of the mind, since the objective mind perceives primarily through the senses. Preoccupation with past and future thoughts, to which the mind becomes habitual, prevents authentic living. Grasping consciousness is essential for embracing the present moment. Exploring beyond consciousness and the senses is essential for teaching the mind how to move beyond sensory desires to clarity, contentment, calmness and clairvoyance. Exploring deeply into the unconscious mind, where thought is not dominant, and awakening the soul to check and guide the monkey mind, is important for self-discovery. Yoga is a compact solution to realizing the purpose of life, encompassing the superconscious state of experiencing full awareness in all states of mind. The only aspect omitted in Yoga is the concept of Advaita Vedanta. Rishi Vashishta, in his prehistoric scripture described as Yog Vashishta, philosophically combined the two, which is now expounded and calculated by quantum physics.
The core of consciousness animates the mind. Consciousness is crucial. Consciousness is different from the mind which acts as an all-purpose tool. It is essential to understand how the mind functions and what its source of energy is. Consciousness drives all mental activity, with the mind as the conduit. The soul is beyond the mind and acts as the centre of consciousness. The soul is the driving force behind thinking, listening, understanding and judging.
If you look closely at your life, you will notice the same recurring patterns. It only works through the mind, which contains used data. The past is stored in your limited mind and no longer exists. Without the active mind, would the past exist? There is only the present. The reality is only the present, but the past remains in our mind. By transcending the mind, you go beyond the bondage of karma. The thought of the past, projected into the future in emotional desires, is a mental trap. But you treat the past as reality, but it is an illusion. The mind is the root of this. By transcending the mind, you overcome everything once and for all.
The core endeavor of spiritual disciplines has always been to transcend the cognitive mind and see life beyond the limitations of the mind. Yoga aims for the individual soul to intuitively become one with the Universal Soul in a state called Samadhi. The focus of yoga is not on the existence of God, but on self-discovery through the illusory play of human experience of the duality of pleasure and pain, happiness and sorrow, to realise that there is no self, only non-dual spiritually conscious energy. When one is present in the mind, the other will inevitably follow and appear.
Yoga is an absolute state that takes one to the superconscious realm of the mind, which is not influenced by imagination or thoughts. One learns how to go beyond the changes of the mind and maintain balance in life by being conscious of one's actions without attachment to the outcome. By not caring about pain and suffering and accepting every situation with grace and respect, the body-mind is liberated through spiritual knowledge and serenity and calm become sublime. Yoga is done through the superconscious realm of the soul and shapes one's attitude with a higher understanding of body, mind, soul and spirit, teaching one how to transcend the spiritualization of life and cognitive mind.
Therefore, if you desire a holistic approach, integrating both practices will provide the most comprehensive benefits. Yoga prepares the body and mind for meditation, and meditation enhances the mental and emotional benefits of yoga. Many feel that practicing both leads to a balanced and fulfilling routine. Whether yoga is better than meditation depends on your personal goals. Incorporating yoga and meditation into your routine can be very effective for a holistic approach to overall health. Ultimately, the most effective practice is the one that resonates with you most and fits into your lifestyle consistently.
Namaste
Leave a Reply